Do AI Overviews Kill Clicks? What the Data Says and What to Measure Instead

Share:
A summary card with a question mark above three result cards and a click arrow

On this page

Is your website helping your business?

Let’s find opportunities to make it work harder for you.

Quick answer

Evidence is mixed and limited. A Pew Research Center study of 900 US adults in March 2025 found users who saw an AI summary clicked a traditional result in 8 per cent of visits, against 15 per cent for those who did not. Google says clicks from such pages are higher quality.

  • Track impressions, clicks, brand searches, enquiries and revenue instead of clicks alone, since AI answers may take some clicks.
  • Make pages worth the click with a calculator, checklist, real example or booking form that a summary cannot offer.
  • Compare the same months year on year in Search Console, check seasonality and see which queries lost clicks.

“AI Overviews are killing clicks” is a common claim. Some of it has evidence behind it, and some of it is guesswork. A Davao business owner needs to know which is which, because it changes what you measure.

Search is Dead. Sound is Now a Prompt. argued that search is changing from typing to talking. Here is what the research says about clicking.

What one study found

The best-known independent study is from Pew Research Center. It analysed browsing data from 900 US adults in March 2025. Users who saw an AI summary clicked a traditional search result link in 8 per cent of visits, compared with 15 per cent for those who did not see one. Clicks on links inside the AI summary were rare, around 1 per cent of visits. Users who saw a summary were also more likely to end their session.

Two bars comparing click rates

Read it carefully. It is a US sample of 900 people, the data is from early 2025 and it measures behaviour on a mix of searches. It does not tell you what happens to a Davao plumber’s local searches in 2026.

What Google says

Google’s guidance says that when people click from results pages with AI Overviews, those clicks are higher quality, meaning people are more likely to spend more time on the site. Google also says AI Overviews show only when they are additive to classic search. These are Google’s own statements, not independent measurements, so treat them as one side of the picture.

Related reading: Google AI Overviews: What They Are and What They Mean for a Davao Business.

What we can reasonably say

  • Some informational searches get answered without a click. Simple definitions and quick facts are the most exposed.
  • The searches that matter to a local service business often involve a decision. People want to compare, check reviews, see prices or book. Those tend to need a website or a map listing.
  • The effect varies by industry and query. Averages hide wide differences.
  • Nobody outside Google has complete data. Beware confident percentages from tool vendors.

Stop measuring only clicks

If AI answers take some clicks, then measuring only clicks undercounts your visibility. Use a ladder of measures.

A ladder from impressions to enquiries
  1. Impressions in the Search Console Generative AI report. See how to check.
  2. Clicks and engaged visits from classic reports and analytics.
  3. Brand searches. If more people search your name, you are being noticed.
  4. Enquiries and bookings. Ask every new customer how they found you.
  5. Revenue from those leads. This is the number that pays the bills.

Social media metrics that matter uses the same idea: choose numbers tied to money.

What to do about it

  • Make your pages worth the click. Offer something the summary cannot: a calculator, a checklist, a real example, a booking form.
  • Make the next step obvious. See headlines that get enquiries.
  • Strengthen what AI cannot replace: reviews, a complete Business Profile, a fast site and clear contact details.
  • Review monthly, using the same method. See the 30-minute audit.

Frequently asked questions

Is my traffic falling because of AI Overviews?

Maybe, maybe not. Compare the same months year on year in Search Console, check for seasonality and look at which queries lost clicks.

Are impressions in AI Overviews worth anything?

They show your pages are being used as sources. Whether that creates value depends on whether people remember or search for you later.

Should I stop publishing informational content?

No, but make each piece earn its place with original detail. See the content audit.

Where do I get Philippine data?

Your own Search Console and analytics. Filter by country.

From the Wired for Growth newsletter

This guide builds on Search is Dead. Sound is Now a Prompt. from Duarne Bernhagen’s LinkedIn newsletter, Wired for Growth.

Sources

Measure what matters

Web Design Davao’s SEO team can set up reporting that tracks enquiries, not just clicks. Ask about reporting.

MORE IDEAS FOR YOUR NEXT STEP

Keep exploring.

Ready for a website with a clearer purpose?

Let’s talk about what your business needs next.

Secret Link